
Work out when your tub runs out
Log your tub in Creatinely and it tells you the day it runs out, based on what you take. It also reminds you every day until you log it.
Every big chain sells creatine now, but the tubs are not the same: different brands, formats and serving sizes. Here is each creatine we found at Walmart, Target, GNC, Vitamin Shoppe and Costco, ranked by what one gram of creatine costs, so you can compare a 450 g tub with a jar of gummies.
Prices checked on each store's website on October 18, 2026.
Some links are affiliate links: if you buy through them, this site may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes the order, which is by price per gram.
11 products
Vitamin Shoppe · 300 caps · Capsules
Vitamin Shoppe · 31.9 oz (904 g) · Powder
3GNC · 90 gummies · Gummies · Creapure
4Walmart · 90 gummies · Gummies
5Walmart · 15.87 oz (450 g) · Powder
6GNC · 120 caps · Capsules
7GNC · 100 servings (~510 g) · Powder
8GNC · 120 gummies · Gummies
Target · 413 g (60 servings) · Powder
Target · 600 g · Powder
11Costco · 240 caps · Capsules
Walmart's own brand, Equate, sells an unflavored creatine monohydrate powder, which works out at — per gram of creatine. It is plain monohydrate with a 5 g scoop, the cheapest tub we found in these chains. Equate also makes creatine gummies, which cost several times more per gram.
Target stocks Optimum Nutrition's creatine monohydrate, unflavored and in flavors. The big unflavored tub was the cheaper of the two per gram; the flavored version costs more per gram because part of the scoop is flavoring.
The supplement chains carry more formats: powder, capsules and gummies, including GNC's own Pro Performance range and BodyTech at Vitamin Shoppe. Both run frequent promotions and membership prices, which we leave out: the table uses the regular price anyone pays.
On costco.com we found one creatine, Sports Research monohydrate in capsules, listed as backordered. Warehouse ranges vary, so your local Costco may have a different one. Capsules cost more per gram than powder, and you need several to reach a 5 g serving.
Store tubs are convenient, but not the cheapest. Every creatine we track in the US, online and in store, is in the full comparison (28 prices).
Plain, unflavored creatine monohydrate powder is the cheapest option per gram. See the table above for the current prices we checked.
If it is creatine monohydrate and contains what the label says, it is the same compound. The difference is usually format, flavor and brand. Third-party lab results are the best way to check a specific product.
When we checked, costco.com listed a creatine monohydrate in capsules (Sports Research, 240 capsules) as backordered. Costco ranges change by warehouse and season, so check your local store.
Usually, for large bags of unflavored powder. The full US comparison lists both.
They cost several times more per gram than powder, and in the independent US and UK lab tests we collected, more than half the gummies tested failed to contain what the label promised.
Price per gram is the shelf price divided by the grams of creatine monohydrate in the pack, not the total weight: flavored powders, capsules and gummies carry other ingredients, so we use the creatine per serving printed on the label. When a label only gives creatine (base), we convert it to monohydrate so every row uses the same unit.
Each price shows the day we last checked it on the store's own page. Prices change often, so check the store before you buy. A price we haven't checked for 30 days is hidden.
Amazon prices only appear once they come from Amazon's own product feed. Until then you'll see a link instead of a price.
"Third-party tested" means a certification (Informed Sport, Informed Choice, NSF Certified for Sport) or a lab test published by someone other than the brand, linked on the product page.

Work out when your tub runs out
Log your tub in Creatinely and it tells you the day it runs out, based on what you take. It also reminds you every day until you log it.